#Deplatforming

There have been calls for pro-Palestine protests to be banned following attacks on Jewish communities. Photo: orlando britain/Alamy Since the shocking attacks on members of the Jewish community in Golders Green, north London on Wednesday, there have been calls to ban future marches in support of Palestinians, including from Jonathan Hall KC, the independent reviewer on terrorism legislation. It sounds like a reasonable demand. There have been expressions of antisemitism on these marches and political slogans are often chanted that many believe to be antisemitic, such as “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free” as well as the phrase “Globalise the intifada”, which has led to arrests for stirring up racial hatred and which the prime minister described as “extreme racism” following the attacks. However, this proposal is unwise for a number of reasons. The Jewish community needs protection, but so does the right to protest. It was significantly eroded by the last Conservative administration and Keir Starmer’s Labour government has already displayed an authoritarian zeal to limit free speech, including new powers that will allow police to put conditions on repeat protests, which became law in April. While this demand for a ban may appear to be targeting hate speech, and in this case specifically antisemitism, it would prevent legitimate and necessary protest. More than 70,000 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza since 7 October 2023 and settler attacks in the West Bank have resulted in multiple deaths and thousands of Palestinians being displaced from their homes. Protest is an essential means of demonstrating public outrage at these events and solidarity with Palestinians. Nor will banning marches diminish the alarming growth in antisemitism, which has become normalised since 7 October. I have myself witnessed a new licence in disparaging Jews and Judaism in public life to a degree that I have never previously observed. It is as if a taboo has been broken. No distinction is made between the actions of Israel and a diaspora minority – not only by the individuals who commit these acts of violence, but even by apparently peace-loving people who would consider themselves to be opposed to racism. This attitude towards Jews has a long history. The belief that the Jewish people are intrinsically evil and out to undermine society dates back to medieval times in England, when they were the most visible minority in the country. That connection between Jews and wrongdoing is so deeply ingrained in our culture (from Chaucer through to Shakespeare, Dickens and Roald Dahl) that anti-Jewish feeling is easily triggered. So, when the Jewish state commits war crimes, it’s the ancient, irrational charges that surface once again: Jews as bloodthirsty child killers seeking to control the world. That’s why the distinction between Jews and Israel is so readily blurred. You don’t stamp out that deep cultural antipathy by banning a march. Instead, you marginalise Palestinians, who are in essential need of international support. You undermine a fundamental democratic right and you fail to address the root causes of antisemitism. You also deny the possibility for a nuanced discussion. I have sympathy with fellow Jews who feel that the chants on marches are hostile and racist. But “Globalise the intifada” and “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free” are political slogans open to interpretation. The Arabic word intifada, or shaking off, is an expression of rebellion against Israeli occupation that dates back nearly 40 years. After nearly 60 years of oppression, supporters of Palestinians have every right to call for it in solidarity. Likewise, “From the river to the sea” could be interpreted as a legitimate call for self-determination or for a one-state solution, which an increasing number of Jews are now calling for too since there is no possibility of a two-state solution in sight. We need to have the courage and vision to support the Jewish community without destroying a fundamental and necessary right. It is Jews who will ultimately be harmed too, as members of the UK population, if the right to protest is further eroded. READ MORE

21 minutes ago

#Deplatforming

Weasel Words: OpenAI’s Pentagon Deal Won’t Stop AI‑Powered Surveillance

OpenAI, the maker of ChaptGPT, is rightfully facing widespread criticism for its decisions to fill the gap the U.S. Department…

The Government Uses Targeted Advertising to Track Your Location. Here’s What We Need to Do.

News Room2 months ago0

We’ve all had the unsettling experience of seeing an ad online that reveals just how much advertisers know about our…

EFF to Third Circuit: Electronic Device Searches at the Border Require a Warrant

News Room2 months ago0

EFF, along with the national ACLU and the ACLU affiliates in Pennsylvania, Delaware, and New Jersey, filed an amicus brief…

Victory! Tenth Circuit Finds Fourth Amendment Doesn’t Support Broad Search of Protesters’ Devices and Digital Data

News Room2 months ago0

In a big win for protesters’ rights, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit overturned a lower court’s…

How to Pick Your Password Manager

News Room2 months ago0

Phishing and data breaches are a constant on the internet. The single best defense against both is to use a…

EFF’s Policy on LLM-Assisted Contributions to Our Open-Source Projects

News Room2 months ago0

We recently introduced a policy governing large language model (LLM) assisted contributions to EFF’s open-source projects. At EFF, we strive…

EFF to Wisconsin Legislature: VPN Bans Are Still a Terrible Idea

News Room2 months ago0

Wisconsin’s S.B. 130 / A.B. 105 is a spectacularly bad idea. It’s an age-verification bill that effectively bans VPN access…

New Report Helps Journalists Dig Deeper Into Police Surveillance Technology

News Room2 months ago0

SAN FRANCISCO — A new report released today offers journalists tips on cutting through the sales hype about police surveillance…

Discord Voluntarily Pushes Mandatory Age Verification Despite Recent Data Breach

News Room3 months ago0

Discord has begun rolling out mandatory age verification and the internet is, understandably, freaking out. At EFF, we’ve been raising…

Speaking Freely: Yazan Badran

News Room3 months ago0

Interviewer: Jillian York Yazan Badran is an assistant professor in international media and communication studies at the Vrije Universiteit Brussel,…

The Internet Still Works: Wikipedia Defends Its Editors

News Room3 months ago0

Section 230 helps make it possible for online communities to host user speech: from restaurant reviews, to fan fiction, to…

EFFecting Change: Get the Flock Out of Our City

News Room3 months ago0

Flock contracts have quietly spread to cities across the country. But Flock ALPR (Automated License Plate Readers) erode civil liberties…

Trending

Workers Voted on Decertifying Unions 1,600 Times in the Past Decade. Teamsters Are the Most Common Target.

Bitcoin (BTC) market cap to hit $16 trillion by 2030, driven by institutional demand: Ark Invest

Weasel Words: OpenAI’s Pentagon Deal Won’t Stop AI‑Powered Surveillance

The Government Uses Targeted Advertising to Track Your Location. Here’s What We Need to Do.

EFF to Third Circuit: Electronic Device Searches at the Border Require a Warrant

Victory! Tenth Circuit Finds Fourth Amendment Doesn’t Support Broad Search of Protesters’ Devices and Digital Data

How to Pick Your Password Manager

EFF’s Policy on LLM-Assisted Contributions to Our Open-Source Projects

EFF to Wisconsin Legislature: VPN Bans Are Still a Terrible Idea

New Report Helps Journalists Dig Deeper Into Police Surveillance Technology

Discord Voluntarily Pushes Mandatory Age Verification Despite Recent Data Breach

Speaking Freely: Yazan Badran

The Internet Still Works: Wikipedia Defends Its Editors

EFFecting Change: Get the Flock Out of Our City

Latest News

Workers Voted on Decertifying Unions 1,600 Times in the Past Decade. Teamsters Are the Most Common Target.

Bitcoin (BTC) market cap to hit $16 trillion by 2030, driven by institutional demand: Ark Invest

Trending

#Deplatforming

Subscribe to Updates

Cookies

Manage Cookies

Your permission applies to the following domains: