Fifth Circuit Comments on District Judge’s Discussion of Using AI in Judicial Decisionmaking

From La Union del Pueblo Entero v. Abbott, decided today by Judge Edith Jones, joined by Judge Kurt Engelhardt and District Judge Robert Summerhays (W.D. La.):

The district court gave an interview to the Wall Street Journal explaining how he had used artificial intelligence as an adjunct to his work on some aspects of a case “involving Texas[ ] election law.” Whether it was this case is uncertain. However, as one distinguished U.S. Senator [Grassley] has commented, AI “must not be a substitute for legal judgment,” nor must the public perceive that federal judges outsource our judgment to AI tools.

Thanks to Michael Smith (Smith Appellate Law Firm) for the pointer.